
U.S. Border Patrol agents dropped a nearly blind refugee at a Tim Horton’s five miles from home in sub-zero Buffalo winter, and he died days later—raising haunting questions about federal duty to the vulnerable.
Story Snapshot
- Nurul Amin Shah Alam, 56-year-old Rohingya refugee, nearly blind and unable to speak English, vanished after Border Patrol release on February 19, 2026.
- Body found on Perry Street February 24 or 25; autopsy ruled death health-related, excluding homicide or exposure.
- Family and attorneys uninformed; drop-off site posed lethal risks in Buffalo’s freezing February weather.
- Officials demand accountability; probes target CBP protocols for disabled detainees.
Rohingya Refugee’s Path to Buffalo
Nurul Amin Shah Alam arrived in Buffalo, New York, in December 2024 as a legal Rohingya refugee fleeing Myanmar persecution. This Muslim father of two joined Buffalo’s growing Myanmar refugee community supported by local aid groups. His near-total blindness required a makeshift curtain rod cane for navigation. Limited English and no phone use isolated him further in this resettlement hub.
Arrest and Year-Long Detention
February 2025 police arrested Shah Alam in Riverside after disorientation during a walk landed him on a woman’s porch. Officers tasered and beat him when he gripped his cane; charges included assault, trespassing, and weapon possession. Erie County held him nearly a year despite his vulnerabilities. On February 9, 2026, Judge James Bargnesi accepted his guilty plea to misdemeanors; bail set at $5,000 with sentencing March 24.
Released February 19 on bail, agents transferred him to U.S. Border Patrol custody despite an immigration detainer. District Attorney Mike Keane expected continued federal hold and learned of the release later, calling it a procedural surprise.
Fatal Drop-Off in Harsh Winter
Border Patrol drove Shah Alam to a Tim Horton’s coffee shop five miles from home in below-freezing Buffalo. Agents released him there without notifying family, attorneys from Legal Aid Bureau of Buffalo, or support networks. Family reported him missing February 21. Buffalo’s February averages lethal cold for a blind man lacking navigation aids on unfamiliar streets.
Discovery and Official Rulings
B District officers found Shah Alam’s body on Perry Street downtown late evening February 24 or 25, after 8:30 PM. Erie County Medical Examiner identified him February 26 morning, notified family, and ruled death health-related. Homicide detectives ruled out homicide and exposure but probe his pre-death timeline. Keane will dismiss charges upon death certificate.
Erie County DA Mike Keane notes the plea weighed Shah Alam’s medical condition, time served, and deportation risks. Keane now reviews processes for lessons to avert repeats, highlighting miscommunication between local and federal authorities.
CBP left a Burmese refugee to die alone in the Buffalo cold.https://t.co/LgwcQ7IoaF
— Half-Assed Buffalo (@HalfAssedBlo) February 26, 2026
Official Reactions and Probes
Governor Kathy Hochul condemned Border Patrol, demanding humanity in border security alongside answers and accountability. Buffalo Mayor Sean Ryan called the death preventable, CBP actions unprofessional and inhumane. Congressman Timothy Kennedy seeks full local, state, federal investigation. CBP has not commented; story develops amid calls for protocol changes.
Implications for Refugees and Enforcement
Shah Alam’s family grieves without closure; Buffalo’s Rohingya community faces eroded trust in authorities. Short-term probes may spur CBP reviews for vulnerable releases. Long-term, lawsuits or training mandates loom, spotlighting tensions in refugee resettlement and federal enforcement. Common sense demands better safeguards—federal power overrides local intent, but humanity checks negligence claims rooted in facts.
Sources:
Nearly blind refugee abandoned by border patrol agents found dead in Buffalo
Man missing since release to Border Patrol dead in Buffalo















