A New York City police officer has reached a $175,000 settlement after exposing the misuse of ‘courtesy cards’ within the NYPD.
At a Glance
- A New York City police officer, Mathew Bianchi, reached a $175,000 settlement with the city over a lawsuit regarding the use of “courtesy cards.”
- The lawsuit claimed Bianchi was punished for not honoring these cards, given to friends and relatives of officers to avoid traffic stops and minor infractions.
- The settlement does not change how the cards are used by NYPD officers.
- Courtesy cards are not officially recognized by the NYPD but are considered a job perk.
- Bianchi advocates for more oversight on the distribution of these cards and protections for those who speak out against their misuse.
The Lawsuit and Settlement
Mathew Bianchi, a New York City police officer, reached a $175,000 settlement with the city over a lawsuit involving the misuse of “courtesy cards.” These cards, distributed by police unions, allow friends and family members of NYPD officers to dodge traffic stops and minor infractions. Bianchi’s lawsuit revealed that he faced punishment for not honoring these cards, which led to his reassignment and hindered his career advancement. The city confirmed the settlement but did not comment further.
Bianchi’s lawyer, John Scola, praised his client’s bravery. “Officer Bianchi displayed remarkable courage by standing up to the NYPD, doing what was right despite the significant risks to his career,” he said.
The officer claimed he faced threats from union officials and precinct supervisors for refusing to overlook the cards. Bianchi reported that he ticketed a friend of Chief Jeffrey Maddrey and was subsequently reassigned to night patrol duties. He also pointed out that the overall culture of card usage remains unchanged within the department. Despite the challenges faced, Bianchi remains committed to advocating for more oversight and ethical practices within the NYPD.
Ongoing Issues and Advocacy
Courtesy cards continue to be a point of contention. Though not officially recognized, they are considered a job perk and are widely used among NYPD officers and their acquaintances. Bianchi notes that while he honored 95% of the courtesy cards, he had concerns about repeat offenders. “They want you to see the card and turn away,” he said.
“It’s a form of corruption,” he said. “My approach to how I handle them is not going to change, even if some boss is going to try to punish me. I’m still going to go out there and I’m going to do exactly what I feel is right.”
Bianchi remains on patrol duty at the 123rd Precinct and continues to push for reforms. He expresses hope that his actions will inspire more officers to come forward as whistleblowers. “I hope the next guy who’s in my position steps up and does what’s right. But things really haven’t changed.”
Public and Institutional Reactions
Mayor Eric Adams’ administration and the NYPD opted not to comment on the matter. The Police Benevolent Association also remained silent on the issue, reflecting the ongoing sensitivity around the use of courtesy cards. The case has reignited discussions on legal fairness and transparency within law enforcement, with many calling for stringent measures to prevent similar misuse in the future.
“Resolving this case was best for all parties,” Nicholas Paolucci, a law department spokesperson, wrote in his statement.
Bianchi’s experience underscores the need for greater accountability and ethical standards within the NYPD. Despite the settlement, there is ongoing debate over how to effectively regulate the distribution and use of courtesy cards to ensure uniform legal treatment for all citizens.
