Carla Hayden’s Departure: Ripple Effects on Federal Agencies and Library Functioning

Man speaking at podium outdoors gesturing with hand

President Trump fired Dr. Carla Hayden as Librarian of Congress with a brief email, ending her historical tenure as the first woman and first person of color to hold the position and sparking concerns about leadership changes at federal cultural institutions.

Quick Takes

Dr. Carla Hayden, the first female and Black Librarian of Congress, was terminated via a brief email from the White House Presidential Personnel Office.
Her firing comes with one year remaining in her term, which began when President Obama nominated her in 2016
The abrupt dismissal aligns with broader Trump administration efforts to remove diversity initiatives across federal agencies
Robert Newlen has been appointed as acting librarian while Democrats have condemned the firing as an attack on intellectual freedom
The Library of Congress, America’s oldest government-run cultural institution, rarely sees leadership changes – Dr. Hayden was the first new librarian since 1987

Dismissal Delivered in Two-Sentence Email

Dr. Carla Hayden, the 14th Librarian of Congress, received notice of her termination through a tersely worded email from Trent Morse, deputy director of White House personnel. The message did not provide any explanation for her sudden dismissal. Appointed by former President Barack Obama in 2016, the 72-year-old Hayden had made history as both the first woman and first African American to lead the prestigious institution. Her term was set to expire next year, making the abrupt termination particularly unexpected for the accomplished librarian who had led the nation’s oldest federal cultural institution for nearly a decade.

“On behalf of President Donald J. Trump, I am writing to inform you that your position as the Librarian of Congress is terminated effective immediately. Thank you for your service” the dismissal email read. The decision has been confirmed by Roswell Encina, a spokesman for the Library of Congress, while Dr. Hayden herself has declined to comment on the situation. Robert Newlen, who has served as the Chief of Staff at the Library of Congress under Hayden’s leadership, will now step in as acting librarian to fill the vacancy created by her removal. The transition marks a significant shift for an institution that rarely experiences leadership changes, with Hayden being the first new librarian appointed since 1987.

Part of Broader Administration Changes

Hayden’s dismissal appears to align with a pattern of broader changes within the Trump administration targeting diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives across federal agencies. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has already removed hundreds of books from the U.S. Naval Academy as part of what critics describe as a DEI-related purge. Conservative groups had previously criticized Hayden for her book selections, with some labeling her approach as “woke.” The Library of Congress, which houses more than 171 million items and serves as the primary research arm of Congress, now faces questions about potential shifts in its mission and operations.

The abrupt change in leadership at such a significant cultural institution has raised concerns about potential impacts on public access to information, the library’s collections, and its research services. During her tenure, Hayden had focused on widening public access to the library’s resources and democratizing information. The unexpected nature of her dismissal has left many questions about the future direction of the Library of Congress and what specific changes might be implemented under new leadership selected by the current administration.

Trump fires Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden in abrupt move, sending Democrats into a frenzy https://t.co/V2F3ofmyVf pic.twitter.com/pSRcQCNnbU

— New York Post (@nypost) May 9, 2025

Reactions from Political Leaders

Democrats have expressed strong opposition to Hayden’s firing, with many praising her accomplishments and questioning the motives behind her removal. Representative Hakeem Jeffries described Hayden as an “accomplished, principled and distinguished” leader whose contributions to the Library of Congress have been significant. The termination has sparked a broader conversation about presidential authority over cultural institutions and the potential politicization of roles traditionally seen as nonpartisan custodians of American history and knowledge.

The Library of Congress, established in 1800, represents the oldest federal cultural institution in the United States and serves as a repository for American history and creativity. Hayden’s sudden departure after such a historic appointment has become emblematic of wider federal reorganization efforts under the current administration. As the transition to interim leadership takes place, observers are watching closely to see who will be nominated as the next Librarian of Congress and what direction the institution will take under new management aligned with the administration’s priorities.